The Inter-American Court of Human Rights. Enviromental, cultural identity and consultation law hermeneutics in light of the case "Lhaka Honhat (nuestra tierra) vs. Argentina (2020)
MetadataShow full item record
Faundes Peñafiel, Juan Jorge
Carmona Caldera, Cristóbal
Silva Sánchez, Pedro Pablo
The main objective of this work is to show how, and with what results, the Inter-American Court of Human Rights recognizes, gives content and establishes a series of general standards for the protection of indigenous peoples. To achieve this aim, the paper analyses the recent judgement of this Court in the "Lhaka Honhat (nuestra tierra) vs. Argentina" case. Thus, it reviews the impact of this ruling within the Argentinean constitutional context and examines the Court's treatment of the right to property, the right to a healthy environment, the right to cultural identity and the right to participation and consultation. It also critically examines the hermeneutical framework used in this and other cases by the Court. The article concludes that the Court develops new categories of rights with the view to strengthen the protection of indigenous peoples, such as the right to a healthy environment and the human right to water, in interdependence with other rights already recognised in its jurisprudence, such as the right to indigenous communal lands, cultural identity and the duty to consult. Nonetheless, the present work points to some issues left open by this decision, such as the difficulties that could derive from the use of the Court's extensive interpretative framework.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
BookFaundes Peñafiel, Juan Jorge; Ramírez, Silvina; Guerrero, Ana Luisa; Salas Astraín, Ricardo; del Carpio Rodríguez, Columba; Vallejos Roa, Liz Daiana; Pacheco Cornejo, Hellen Teresita; Chacana Hidalgo, Susana; Cattaruzzi Gerasimczuk, Livia; Hartung, Pedro; ... (Universidad Autónoma de Chile, 2020-12-01)
Fundamental right to the cultural identity of indigenous peoples: A new paradigm in indigenous criminal defense in Chile in the face of the hegemonic Rule of Law [Derecho fundamental a la identidad cultural de los pueblos indígenas: Un nuevo paradigma en la defensa penal indígena en Chile frente al Estado de Derecho hegemónico] (2020) Peñafiel J.J.F. (Universidad de Santiago de Chile, 2019)
Fundamental right to the cultural identity of indigenous peoples, configuration in accordance with international law and perspectives for its reception in Chile [El derecho fundamental a la identidad cultural de los pueblos indígenas, configuración conforme el derecho internacional y perspectivas de su recepción en Chile] (2020) Peñafiel J.J.F. (Universidad de Talca, 2020)