Initiatives for reporting biomedical research results with different types of designs [Iniciativas disponibles para el reporte de resultados en investigación biomédica con diferentes tipos de diseño]
Autor
Manterola C.
Otzen T.
Lorenzini N.
Díaz A.
Torres-Quevedo R.
Claros N.
Resumen
Quality of results reporting is not perfect, many initiatives tending to improve this aspect of clinical research have been developed in the last decade. The aim of this manuscript is to mention and describe the existent initiatives for reporting biomedical research results in different scenarios and special situations. To obtain check-lists, a search in THE COCHRANE LIBRARY, MEDLINE, SciELO y Redalyc; Clinical Evidence, TRIP database, Fisterra, Rafabravo, EQUATOR Network, BIREME and HINARI Program was developed. Identified documents were grouped in relation with clinical research scenarios (therapy, diagnosis, prognosis and economic evaluations) and miscellaneous. The search allows finding 31 documents. Twelve for therapy (CONSORT, QUOROM, MOOSE,STRICTA, TREND, MINCIR-Therapy, RedHot, REHBaR, PRISMA,REFLECT, Ottawa and SPIRIT), 5 for diagnosis (STARD, QUADAS, QAREL, GRRAS and MINCIR-Diagnosis), 3 for prognosis (REMARK, MINCIR-Prognosis and GRIPS), 4 for economic evaluations (NHSHTA, CHEERS, ISPOR RCT-CEA and NICE-STA,) and 7 miscellaneous (STROBE, COREQ, GRADE, SQUIRE, STREGA, ORION and MINCIR-EOD). Different initiatives and statements were found. These must be noted and used by writers, reviewers and editors of biomedical journals, in order to improve the quality of reporting results.
Colecciones
Ítems relacionados
Mostrando ítems relacionados por Título, autor o materia.
-
Article
Checklist for reporting results using observational descriptive studies as research designs. The MInCir initiative [Lista de Verificación para Reporte de Resultados Usando Estudios Observacionales Descriptivos como Diseños de Investigación. La Iniciativa MInCir] (2020)
Manterola C.; Otzen T. (Universidad de la Frontera, 2017) -
Review
Walter thiel’s embalming method. Review of solutions and applications in different fields of biomedical research [Método de embalsamamiento de walther thiel. Revisión de las soluciones y sus aplicaciones en diferentes campos de investigación biomédica] (2020)
Ottone N.E.; Vargas C.A.; Fuentes R.; Del Sol M. (Universidad de la Frontera, 2016) -
Article
Reliability and validity of MINCIR scale for methodological quality in dental therapy research (2020)
Cartes-velásquez R.A.; Manterola C.; Aravena P.; Moraga J. (Sociedade Brasileira de Hematologia e Hemoterapia, 2014)